Spunk Odds Reference

Scratch cards guide

Candy Scratch: how break-even prizes inflate the win rate

Candy is a page label, not a product; treat it like a folder name. What follows compares two made-up print runs that pay out exactly the same total yet advertise very different chances of winning.

What a break-even prize is

A break-even prize returns the price of the ticket and nothing more. On paper it is a win. In your pocket it changes nothing: you paid 1 unit and got 1 unit back. Many instant-win designs include a large tier of these, often called a "free ticket" or "money back" prize.

The design choice matters because the overall odds figure counts tickets, not money. Every break-even ticket adds one winner to the count at very low cost to the prize fund.

Design A: heavy on refunds

Design A (hypothetical): 500,000 tickets at 1.00, with a large break-even tier
PrizeTicketsOddsExpected value per ticket
2,000.00101 in 50,000.00.0400
100.001001 in 5,000.00.0200
20.001,0001 in 500.00.0400
5.008,0001 in 62.50.0800
2.0025,0001 in 20.00.1000
1.00100,0001 in 5.00.2000

134,110 winning tickets out of 500,000 (overall 1 in 3.73). Prize fund 240,000.00 on sales of 500,000.00: return 48.00%, so a ticket at 1.00 is worth 0.4800 on average. Hypothetical print run.

Design B: no refunds, smaller prizes doubled

Design B rebuilds the two lowest tiers. Each keeps the same share of the fund, but with half as many tickets paying double, so the refund of 1 unit becomes 2 units and the 2-unit tier becomes 4. The upper tiers are left untouched, so the prize fund does not change.

Design B (hypothetical): same 500,000 tickets and same prize fund, no break-even tier
PrizeTicketsOddsExpected value per ticket
2,000.00101 in 50,000.00.0400
100.001001 in 5,000.00.0200
20.001,0001 in 500.00.0400
5.008,0001 in 62.50.0800
4.0012,5001 in 40.00.1000
2.0050,0001 in 10.00.2000

71,610 winning tickets out of 500,000 (overall 1 in 6.98). Prize fund 240,000.00 on sales of 500,000.00: return 48.00%, so a ticket at 1.00 is worth 0.4800 on average. Hypothetical print run.

Side by side

Designs A and B compared (both hypothetical)
MeasureDesign ADesign B
Prize fund (units)240,000240,000
Return to player48.00%48.00%
Advertised overall odds1 in 3.731 in 6.98
Odds of finishing ahead1 in 14.661 in 6.98

Both runs are invented. Only the bottom of the prize table differs.

Design A prints the friendlier headline, 1 in 3.73 against 1 in 6.98. Yet the expected value per ticket is identical, and a buyer of Design B is more likely to walk away with more than they paid: 14.32% of its tickets show a gain, compared with 6.82% for Design A.

So the break-even tier does one job well: it makes the card look generous. It also hands the buyer a reason to buy another ticket, since a refund is commonly taken as a new card rather than cash. Over a session that loop tends to recycle the money until a losing ticket ends it.

How to adjust for it yourself

  1. Find the tier whose prize equals the ticket price.
  2. Subtract its ticket count from the total number of winners.
  3. Divide the print run by what is left. That is the odds of a real gain.

For a fuller look at the headline figure on a different run, see the overall odds guide. The general case is set out in the scratch card overview.